eight bottles (or should i say att botla)

Tuesday 11th November 2008 08:58:52 PM

My eldest cousin always forwards me text messages, sometimes they're funny, sometimes they're not and mostly they're riddles like the one I got today. Usually I can figure them out but today I'm not having much luck. Even the sizzling brain power of Abz couldn't help me so I'm posting it here.

>> Two men and a woman were stuck in a lift during a heatwave. 1 of the men had 3 bottles of water with him and the other had 5. They shared the eight bottles of water equally between the 3 of them. Once they had been freed, the woman gave the men £8 as payment. What is the fairest method of dividing the money.

Now I'm thinking why the hell did the woman have to be such a b1tch and give the men £8 ... cos knowing the riddle but not the answer will get me thinking at odd hours of the night (when I could be using that valuable time to think of something else).

You wouldn't know the answer by any chance would you?

Posted by Piniyini

<< motivation   Toseef's Blog   its all about sleeping >>

post comments feed9 comments       Ctrl + Enter to comment
Tue 11th Nov 08 09:13:46 PM 1 Specs

This is from a famous anecdote (dunno authentic or not) about Hazrat Ali (RA).

Using the logic from that here, each person consumed 8/3= 2 and 2/3rd of a bottle. That means that the person with 3 bottles consumed 2 2/3rd of his own... and only shared 1/3 with the woman. The woman also consumed 8/3 of the total of which only 1/3 came from this man. The rest 7/3 came from the other.

Man with 5 bottles gets 7 quid. The other gets 1.

Tue 11th Nov 08 11:21:56 PM 2 Specs

Just on a side note, if they were REAL men, they woulda given her all 8 bottles...AND not taken the money.

Guys nowadays have no chivalry left, I swear.

Wed 12th Nov 08 11:40:04 AM 3 Abdul Sami Mughal

n i swear that everytime i hav tried chivalry i m either accused of being rude, sexist.. or even chauvinist...

but to be fair... if they were real men... what is that supposed to mean... :S !!!

is that what real men means these days... ???

Thu 13th Nov 08 05:11:51 PM 4 Smee

wow speccie, your calculations are done with such ease they kinda threw me for a bit.
but anyway *round of applause for the specster*
yay!

Thu 13th Nov 08 07:15:33 PM 5 Piniyini

Specs, I think you're going to be my first point of contact for any future unsolvable riddles. Thank you, thank you ...

(btw I had to read it a few times to get my head round it, fantastic logic!)

Fri 14th Nov 08 09:18:44 PM 6 Aapa

im surprised you got it even after reading it a few times!

Sun 16th Nov 08 11:35:16 AM 7 Beeamma

eeeeeeeh?

Sun 16th Nov 08 11:35:18 AM 8 Beeamma

eeeeeeeh?

Sun 16th Nov 08 04:38:12 PM 9 Piniyini

Bee, whatdya mean? (oh i emailed ya but it bounced)

<< motivation   Toseef's Blog   its all about sleeping >>
Post a comment   Track comments
Search

Feeds (Subscribe via Google Reader)
blog posts feed Blog Posts
recent comments feed Recent Comments

Archives
2011  Sep  Oct
2010  Feb
2009  Jan  Mar  Apr  May  Jun  Jul  Oct  Nov
2008  Jan  Feb  Apr  May  Jul  Oct  Nov  Dec
2007  Jan  Feb  Mar  Apr  May  Jun  Jul  Aug  Sep  Oct  Nov  Dec
2006  Jan  Feb  Mar  May  Jun  Jul  Aug  Sep  Oct  Nov  Dec
2005  Jan  Feb  Mar  Apr  May  Jun  Jul  Aug  Sep  Oct  Nov  Dec
2004  Aug  Sep  Nov  Dec
Recent Comments
Check out my Blog Roll

Says thanks to the following poeple for recently leaving a comment ...

Hardware Keylogger
Campaign Yard Sign
Cheap Air Jordans
Jordans For Sale
Best Forum Hosting
Essay Help
Comprar Viagra
Precio Viagra
Commercial Loans
Viagra Sildenafil
Iphone Development Company
Cheap Domain Name Registration
Website Hosting Forum
Web Design
Essay Writing Uk